(Bishkek) - Kyrgyzstan is convicting hundreds of people for possessing videos, pamphlets, and books that it has banned using a dangerously overbroad definition of extremism, Human Rights Watch said in a report released today. Offenders are sentenced to 3 to 10 years in prison even if they did not distribute the material or use it to incite violence.
The 78-page report, "'We Live in Constant Fear': Possession of Extremist Material in Kyrgyzstan," finds that in some cases, suspects are charged for possessing material that the authorities classified as extremist only after their arrests. Several suspects told Human Rights Watch that police and security agents had planted the material during searches, then demanded payoffs to end investigations. Some said law enforcement officials tortured them to extract confessions.
September 17, 2018 Report "We Live in Constant Fear" Possession of Extremist Material in Kyrgyzstan
Download the full report in English Download the summary and recommendations in Kyrgyz Download the summary and recommendations in Uzbek
"Kyrgyzstan should prosecute people for committing or plotting violence, but not for the videos they watch or the books they read," said Letta Tayler, senior terrorism and counterterrorism researcher at Human Rights Watch and the report's author. "Outlawing mere possession of material vaguely defined as extremist makes it all too easy to unjustly target political opponents, activists, journalists, defense lawyers, and ordinary citizens."
Human Rights Watch interviewed 70 people for the report, most during two visits to Kyrgyzstan, in 2017 and 2018. They included 11 people accused or convicted in these cases, family members of 13 suspects, 17 local human rights defenders and lawyers, and government officials. Human Rights Watch also reviewed 34 court cases and other government documents.
In many cases, the material used in prosecutions did not contain explicit calls for violence, Human Rights Watch found. However, some of the material consisted of recruitment videos or other propaganda for Islamist armed groups. Much of it was from Hizb ut-Tahrir, a pan-national group banned in Kyrgyzstan that calls for an Islamic caliphate but publicly disavows violence.
Interview: How Not to Fight Terrorism
Central Asian governments fear that Islamist armed groups like ISIS are moving closer to the region. As part of efforts to stop these groups from gaining a regional foothold, Kyrgyzstan is imprisoning people for possessing so-called "extremist materials." Senior researcher Letta Tayler describes why this tactic could do more harm than good.
READ THE INTERVIEW HERE
"We live in constant fear that at any moment, someone will knock on our door with a warrant and take us to prison on false evidence," said "Sukhrob," who was convicted in 2017 for possessing a years-old magazine and three pages of literature. Sukhrob said the material was planted.
The prosecutions are part of a broader crackdown in Kyrgyzstan and other Central Asian countries in the name of countering Islamist extremism. Nationals from the region and its diaspora have been implicated in seven attacks by groups such as the Islamic State (also known as ISIS) from June 2016 to July 2018. The attacks killed at least 117 people and injured more than 360.
Human Rights Watch unequivocally condemns such attacks and recognizes that governments have an obligation to protect those under their jurisdiction from harm. However, international law requires governments to define criminal offenses precisely and to respect freedom of expression, including the right to hold even deeply offensive views.
Prosecutions for possessing extremist material in Kyrgyzstan are carried out under article 299-2 of the criminal code, the country's most widely applied charge against terrorism and extremism suspects. At least 258 people have been convicted under article 299-2 since 2010. According to the most recent data available, several hundred suspects are awaiting trial on the charge and the numbers have increased each year, with 167 new cases opened during the first nine months of 2016.
Since 2013, article 299-2 has criminalized possession of material deemed extremist even if the accused has no intent to disseminate it, making the measure a particularly severe threat to freedom of speech, belief, and expression. Parliament has approved amendments to restore an earlier requirement that possession of extremist material must be "for the purpose of dissemination" to be unlawful. However, government officials have suggested that the amendments may be delayed beyond their scheduled start date of January 2019. The authorities should put the amendments into effect as swiftly as possible.
Moreover, these amendments will not change article 299-2's reliance on overbroad definitions of extremism in Kyrgyzstan's 2005 Law on Countering Extremist Activity, which include "affronts to national dignity," "hooliganism," and "vandalism." The determination of whether material is extremist is made by the State Commission for Religious Affairs, which human rights defenders have criticized for insufficient expertise and impartiality. The government has pledged to transfer the reviews to specially trained forensic experts and should do so as soon as possible.
Most article 299-2 arrests are carried out by police from the Ministry of Internal Affairs' 10th Department or the counterterrorism forces of the State Committee for National Security (GKNB). When asked for comments on alleged abuses including evidence planting and torture by these forces, some government authorities did not respond, while others said any wrongdoing was the work of a few rogue officers.
Kyrgyzstan, a former Soviet Republic, is officially a secular state. The population is 80 percent Muslim. A 2016 Supreme Court study found that the majority of suspects prosecuted in Kyrgyzstan for terrorism and extremism offenses, including article 299-2, are ethnic Uzbeks from the south. Ethnic Uzbeks comprise less than 15 percent of the population, with the highest concentration in southern Kyrgyzstan, the most religiously conservative part of the country.
Human Rights Watch is not in a position to determine whether article 299-2 is being used to target people on the basis of ethnicity or particular religious views. However, many Uzbek suspects and family members believe this is the case, turning these prosecutions into a potential source of tension.
Since 2012, between 2,600 and 5,000 Central Asians, including 764 from Kyrgyzstan, are estimated to have traveled to Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan to join or live under armed groups such as ISIS, Jabhat al-Nusra, and the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan. The numbers are subject to debate and include family members and others who did not perform combat functions.
The authorities in Kyrgyzstan should revamp article 299-2 and Kyrgyzstan's overly broad definition of extremism. The country's courts should promptly review all convictions for mere possession of extremist material.
"Abusive counterterrorism measures are not only unlawful, they can alienate local communities," Tayler said. "Instead of keeping the public safer, they risk generating support for extremist armed groups."
Source: Human Rights Watch